EP 59: How to Build Hunting Arrows Using the 2026 Arrow Ballistic Data
Part one was the data. This one is what you do with it. Zakk walks through how he’d actually build a hunting arrow off the 2026 Arrow Ballistics Study — how to pick a broadhead, how much vane you really need, and how to chase FOC without wrecking the trajectory that makes your setup work. He does it out loud on his own bow, with his own numbers on the table: 465 grains, mid-280s, and an FOC of 11.9% he’s no longer sure he’s happy with.
Jump to
- Where Part One Left Off
- What “Flies Better” Means
- When Fixed Blades Still Make Sense
- 15 Decibels of Spread
- The Arrow, Not the Bow
- Broadhead Selection Priority
- Using the Vane Data
- Trajectory and Ranging Errors
- The Scatter Plot
- Over 310 fps? Go Stiffer
- FOC: The One He’s Chewing On
- His Own Numbers
- What the Study Found
- Three Paths to More FOC
- His Honest Assessment
- Build It as a System
- The Five-Step Framework
- Tune the Bow First
- What Changes at the Shop
- Zakk’s Next Step
Listen to the full episode on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, YouTube or stream below.
We discuss:
Timestamps refer to the audio/video episode above.
- Quick recap of the study: four days in the Easton lab, 23 vane configurations, two speeds, and the first formal FOC protocol
- What “mechanicals fly more forgivingly” does and does not mean — this is external ballistics only
- When a fixed blade still makes sense, and why confidence in your equipment is the real variable
- Why new shooters and low-volume shooters should be on a quality mechanical
- A 15 decibel spread from quietest to loudest broadhead — roughly three times as loud
- Why the arrow, not the bow, is the sound a deer reacts to
- Zakk’s three-part priority for choosing a broadhead
- How to actually apply the vane data: pick the broadhead first, then be honest about your shooting
- Misranging as the most common cause of misses at distance
- The three-axis scatter plot, and why seeing it beats reading about it
- Shooting over 310 fps? The data says go to a stiffer vane material
- FOC: the takeaway Zakk hasn’t stopped thinking about
- His actual setup — PSE Mach 33, FMJ Max, 465 grains, mid-280s, 11.9% FOC
- Does more FOC even matter for 35-yard whitetail shots?
- +5 points of FOC predicts a four-inch tighter group at 70 yards, with no accuracy ceiling
- Why he won’t just stack point weight onto his current arrow
- Path one: cutting the arrow shorter
- Path two: dropping to a lower GPI shaft — the option he’s leaning toward
- Path three: reclaiming weight from the vanes
- Why you can’t optimize any one piece in isolation
- The five-step framework for building an arrow from scratch off this data
- Retune after every meaningful FOC change — and tune the bow before anything else
- How the study changes the conversation at Extreme Outfitters
- Zakk’s next step on his own arrows, and what he’ll report back
00:00Where Part One Left Off
This episode builds directly on part one, and Zakk says up front that it won’t fully land without that foundation. If you haven’t heard it, start there — the feedback and the back-and-forth it generated is a good chunk of why this follow-up exists.
The short version: the 2026 Arrow Ballistics Study was run by James Yates in partnership with Easton, Hoyt and Precision Cut Archery over four days in March 2026 in the Easton lab. They used a pneumatic shooting machine, Doppler radar, chronographs and an independent acoustic testing chamber. They measured drag, lift recovery and accuracy across 23 different vane configurations and a wide range of broadheads, at two speeds — 290 feet per second and 325-plus feet per second. And for the first time, they formally tested FOC, the weight distribution of the arrow.
Last week was the data. This week is what you do with it, and Zakk gets personal with it, because his current setup has an FOC of right around 11.9% and going through the study left him with real questions about whether that’s where he wants to be.
01:40Broadheads: What “Flies Better” Actually Means
For most hunters, Zakk thinks the arrow building conversation begins with broadheads, and it’s a hot topic with a ton of opinions attached. The study confirmed, for the second year in a row, that mechanical broadheads fly more forgivingly than fixed blades: tighter groups downrange, more consistent flight.
That isn’t a surprise at this point. But Zakk is careful about the boundary of the claim, and this is the part he thinks people will run past.
“This is an external ballistics test only. The study does not test what happens when a broadhead hits bone. It didn’t test blade retention, pass-through, or what a mechanical does versus a fixed blade on a quartering-away elk.” — Zakk Plocica
Those are completely separate conversations, and he thinks they matter enormously. What the study tells us is about flight characteristics. Nothing more, and nothing less.
03:09So When Does a Fixed Blade Still Make Sense?
Given mechanicals fly better, that’s the real question — and Zakk’s answer comes back to personal preference and personal testing. There are very good performing mechanicals and very good performing fixed blades. What matters more is which one you’ve actually tested and which one you trust.
“When you’re confident with your equipment, you’re confident in the woods. Whenever you go to draw back on an animal, the likelihood of you making a good shot is substantially higher versus whenever you lack confidence in your equipment.” — Zakk Plocica
Look at your hunting style, the animal you’re hunting, and what you’re comfortable with, then decide from there. The study gives you the information; interpreting it and applying it to your situation is on you. Zakk doesn’t think one is categorically better than the other — and if you’re well-versed, if you’ve spent a lot of time behind your bow, you can get away with whatever you want, because your shooting ability carries it.
New shooters are the exception he’ll draw a line under. If you don’t understand broadhead tuning, or you don’t shoot enough to have a dialed-in shot process, you need forgiveness, and the mechanical is the superior choice. With one condition attached: a good quality mechanical, not the cheap stuff. Look at the high performers in the test results and buy accordingly — the animal you’re shooting deserves it.
05:26Sound: 15 Decibels From Quietest to Loudest
The spread from the quietest broadhead in the study to the loudest is about 15 decibels. On a logarithmic scale, that’s roughly three times as loud.
The combination testing — vanes paired with broadheads — proved that both choices matter. A quiet vane paired with a quiet broadhead makes a meaningfully quieter arrow than either one alone. Which is Zakk’s recurring theme for the whole episode: when you’re building arrows, the vane and the broadhead are one system, not two separate decisions.
06:08Deer React to the Arrow, Not the Bow
Yates believes deer react to the sound of the arrow rather than the sound of the bow. There’s a lot of conversation around that — some people land on the bow, some on the arrow — and Zakk’s own view is that if you can quiet both down it makes sense to, but that the arrow probably deserves the priority.
“The bow makes that short, single, non-continuous noise. It goes off, boom, that’s it. But the arrow is continuous. It’s a continuous hiss tracking straight towards the animal that gets louder as it gets closer. That’s a threat.” — Zakk Plocica
A deer’s instinct is to respond to an approaching threat, and the arrow is the thing approaching. That’s why building a quiet system has been a priority for Yates, why it’s become more of one for Zakk, and why he’d recommend it to anyone hunting pressured whitetail or elk in quiet timber. The difference now is that it’s a data-backed recommendation instead of an opinion.
07:14Zakk’s Broadhead Selection Priority
If you’re rebuilding your arrow setup after this study, here’s the order he’d work in:
- Does it fly well at your speed? Not in general — at the speed your bow is actually shooting. Check the accuracy data from the study.
- Is it quiet? Check the sound data from the study.
- Does it fit your hunting application in terms of terminal performance? Meaning the behavior and destructive effect of the projectile.
All three matter. The study covers the first two, and you have to answer the third yourself based on your own experience. There are plenty of videos out there, but Zakk rates firsthand experience above all of it, and he’s honest that it takes time — probably a season or more — to get right. The study just gets you started in the right direction.
08:25How to Actually Use the Vane Data
23 configurations were tested, with drag, lift recovery and noise measured simultaneously. Here’s how Zakk thinks about applying that.
Step one: decide what broadhead you’re shooting
That decision determines how much lift recovery you actually need. If you’re shooting a quality mechanical that groups like a field point, you don’t need a massive vane. The AAE Talon is incredible at steering a fixed blade or a bigger broadhead — but it’s also bigger, and bigger means more drag. If your mechanical doesn’t need that much steering, you’re carrying more drag than you need, and something smaller like the Flex Fletch 360 gets you quieter flight with less drag while still offering plenty of recovery for the head you’re running.
Step two: be honest about your shooting
This is the personal one, and Zakk thinks most people aren’t as honest with themselves here as they should be. We all overestimate our capability at some point. If you rush your shots when adrenaline hits, if you hunt from awkward angles, if your shot process just isn’t dialed in — you need more vane than the minimum.
“These are not character flaws. We’re all just human. Some of us perform better under pressure than others. Just build your arrow to counter that. More vane forgives more mistakes.” — Zakk Plocica
That little bit more lift isn’t a bad thing — it helps you in the long run and improves your recovery rate on the animals you shoot. If you’re a genuinely disciplined shooter with consistent form, you can run less vane and optimize for drag and noise. Just take a step back and be realistic first. Do you shoot year-round, or do you pick the bow up when the season starts? Answer that honestly before you make the call.
11:07Step Three: How Much Does Flat Trajectory Matter to You?
For Western hunting — and for Total Archery Challenge style shooting at long and sometimes extreme distances — a flatter trajectory is non-negotiable. The reason is simple: misranging is probably the most common cause of misses at distance. The flatter your arrow flies, the more range forgiveness you have.
A vane with more drag costs you speed and adds arc. So if trajectory matters to you, you want to minimize drag within the constraint of having enough lift recovery for your broadhead. Back to the same idea — you’re weighing one against the other based on where you hunt and how far you shoot, not optimizing a single number.
11:52The Three-Axis Scatter Plot Does the Work
The plot on the Precision Cut Archery site brings all of this together visually: drag on one axis, lift recovery on the other, noise shown as color. It’s interactive — hover over any dot for the specific data, click it to see the actual arrow groups from the study.
“It just makes the trade-offs obvious in a way that it’s really hard for me to describe in words.” — Zakk Plocica
Zakk’s straightforward about it: when he can look at something visually and manipulate it, he understands how the pieces work together far better than he does from a description. Go look at it on a screen and the vane options for your chosen broadhead sort themselves out.
12:31Shooting Over 310 fps? Go Stiffer
One specific finding worth calling out: if you’re shooting over 310 feet per second, the study confirms you should go to a stiffer vane material. The Flex Fletch 360X outperformed the standard 360 at 325 feet per second — same vane, stiffer version.
Manufacturers have been saying this for years; now there’s data behind it. And it’s increasingly relevant, because there are a lot of guys shooting those speeds now. Between the PSE Sicarios and the Mathews ARCs, plenty of setups are pushing 310 to 320 feet per second. Pay attention to vane material stiffness, not just vane profile — especially when you’re pairing that vane with a broadhead.
13:49FOC: The Takeaway He Hasn’t Stopped Thinking About
Zakk calls FOC the biggest takeaway from the study, and the one that’s been in his head since he read it. He’s also upfront that he’s still on the fence about what to do with it.
14:20His Own Numbers, On the Table
His current hunting setup is a PSE Mach 33 with the EC2 cam, set up at 28.5 inches, around 76 to 78 pounds. The arrow is an Easton FMJ Max at 465 grains, shooting in the mid-280s. He measured his FOC — something he’d never bothered with before, because it had never been that important to him — and it came in right at 11.9%.
After the 2026 study, he thinks that number is on the low end. The question he works through out loud is whether it actually matters for the hunting he does. His hunting is East Coast whitetail, and his shots are typically inside 35 yards.
The honest accounting on last season: he had no penetration issues at all, with any deer he shot. Everything passed through like it was nothing. He was running the SEVR 1.75 Hybrid, and the flight was incredibly good — there was blood on impact with every single deer, and every deer was recovered. He has no complaints. The open question is only whether it could be better.
16:23What the Study Actually Found
Increasing FOC by 5 percentage points — say, going from 13% to 18% — predicts a two inch reduction in broadhead group mean radius. Mean radius is half the group diameter, so two inches on the mean radius is four inches on the full group spread at 70 yards. That’s substantial.
And there’s no sweet spot ceiling. Accuracy just kept improving as FOC continued to increase. The caveat is that it’s limited by dynamic spine tolerance and trajectory — not by accuracy falling off.
Zakk is clear-eyed about how that maps onto him. He’s not shooting 70 yards at animals. He does want to hunt out West one day, and that’s where he thinks this really matters. Theoretically, based on the study, he should be pushing closer to 15 to 17% FOC, maybe more.
17:15Why He Won’t Just Add Point Weight — and the Three Paths That Are Left
Here’s the constraint. He’s running roughly 80 pounds and a 28.5 inch draw specifically because he wants a flatter trajectory — he’s chasing speed so he can shoot a slightly heavier arrow flatter, further. Range forgiveness is the priority, because a misranged shot with a heavy arrow drops a long way, and that’s the difference between a clean kill and a wounded or missed animal.
So if he just adds a bunch of point weight to hit a higher FOC, the arrow gets sluggish. It’s already 465 grains in the mid-280s. The arc increases and he gives up the ranging buffer he built the setup around.
“I don’t think that’s a trade that I’m willing to make blindly. I don’t even know if I’m willing to make it at all at this point.” — Zakk Plocica
Which turns the question into: how do you get meaningfully more FOC without sacrificing the trajectory that makes the setup work? This is where Yates’ three paths get practical.
| Path | What It Does | The Trade-Off | Where Zakk Lands |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Cut the arrow shorter (18:56) | Moves the balance point forward and stiffens dynamic spine at the same time | Limited by clearance — he thinks he has close to an inch left on the FMJ Max | Worth testing, but he doubts it moves FOC dramatically on its own |
| 2. Drop to a lower GPI shaft (19:43) | Lighter shaft frees up weight you can move to the front, raising FOC at a similar total arrow weight | Lower GPI shafts are less durable than an FMJ Max or Axis 5mm | The one he’s leaning toward — “it just seems to make more sense” |
| 3. Lighter vanes (23:39) | Every grain of vane weight eliminated is a grain you can add up front | Only works if you’re running more vane than your broadhead actually needs | Doesn’t think he is, but says it’s worth testing |
Path two, in his own numbers
This is the one he spends the most time on. He’s currently running the FMJ Max with a stock insert and collar. He could stay in the 5mm category and move to an Easton 5.0, where the GPI is substantially lower. From there he could add a 75 grain HIT insert and run a 125 grain point instead of a 100 — internally, which is exactly how the study added weight, since all of their FOC increases were internal with no outserts. Same ballpark total weight, substantially greater FOC.
The trade-off he names honestly is durability. The FMJ Max, or an Axis 5mm which is nearly identical on GPI, is a more durable arrow than a lower GPI shaft. He’s personally had zero durability issues with the 5.0, but he can see a lot of added point weight introducing some — though if you cut the shaft short enough to really stiffen it, he doesn’t think you should technically have problems.
What makes it attractive is the stacked win: keep total weight similar, shift weight forward, raise FOC, and potentially even drop overall arrow weight a little for more speed. As the test showed, the high speed setups were still incredibly accurate. More speed, flatter trajectory, higher FOC, lighter shaft — that reads like a win on every axis he cares about.
On the vane side
For path three, the vanes he weighs are the AAE Max Stealth, which has performed exceptionally well for him over the years and is still plenty quiet with good steering; the DCA Super Sabre, which he calls one of the best performing vanes in the study for lift recovery, drag and quietness together; and the Bohning Heat, which is stiffer and still fairly quiet — a good option if you’re shooting fast, though he notes he isn’t going to see 310 feet per second, so stiffness matters less for him.
23:56His Honest Assessment
“My honest assessment: 11.9% FOC is probably leaving real broadhead accuracy on the table. The study says the improvement is measurable and significant.” — Zakk Plocica
He may start by shortening the arrow, but he’s leaning harder toward changing the arrow itself — a lower GPI shaft, with FOC gained that way. He’ll likely test both against each other and report back, either in a future episode or on his personal social media, with the caveat that human error enters the picture the moment he’s the one shooting.
26:03The Thing That Gets Lost If You Just Scroll the Charts
Everything in this study is connected. Your broadhead choice affects how much vane you need. Your vane choice affects how much weight you have available for FOC. Your FOC affects trajectory. Your trajectory affects your ranging forgiveness.
“You can’t optimize one piece in isolation. You really have to think about this as a whole system.” — Zakk Plocica
He’s careful to aim that at the right audience. If you’re new, you don’t need any of this — get some stock arrows with vanes on them and go shoot. They’ll perform well. This is for the people who are genuinely into building their own arrows, where thinking about the whole system instead of individual components is where the remaining performance actually lives.
26:54The Five-Step Framework for Building From Scratch
If Zakk were sitting down to build arrows from scratch using this data, this is the order he’d work in.
1. Decide your speed and trajectory priority
Are you hunting variable distances where ranging error is a real risk — the guys out West, the guys taking genuinely long shots? Then speed and flatness are critical: keep total arrow weight reasonable and minimize drag. Or are you in tighter timber and thicker vegetation with close shot windows? Then you have more flexibility on total weight and can shoot a heavier arrow.
2. Choose your broadhead
Based on your hunting application plus the noise and accuracy data. On fixed blades, he points to the Toulou and the Iron Will Solids for the quieter options, and the Tooth of the Arrow if you’re running a faster setup — it surprised him how much better that head performed as bow speed increased. On mechanicals, the SEVR family is phenomenal and he’s a big fan, SEVR has a new head that just dropped, Evolution Outdoors has topped the charts over and over, and the Beast Titanium performed exceptionally well. Any of those give you quiet flight and excellent accuracy.
3. Choose your vane based on the broadhead
That’s the order — the broadhead decision comes first, the vane serves it.
| If you’re shooting… | Zakk points you to | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Fixed blades | AAE Talon or Hybrid HP | You need the steering those profiles provide |
| Mechanicals | Flex Fletch 360, 300, or the UV Vane | Quiet and low drag while still offering enough recovery |
| Somewhere in the middle | DCA Super Sabre | Bridges the two worlds better than anything else tested — and has been a hot seller at the shop |
4. Maximize FOC within your trajectory limits
Cut the arrow shorter, drop the shaft GPI, use lighter vanes, and direct the weight you free up toward the front.
5. Tune the bow
Which is important enough that it gets its own section below.
29:39Retune Every Time — and Tune the Bow Before Any of This
Any meaningful change to your FOC means retuning. The study retuned the bow for every single FOC category in the matrix, so this isn’t optional: a mistuned bow with great FOC is still a mistuned bow.
And underneath everything else is the fundamental. The shooting machine in the study puts field points essentially in one hole at 70 yards when the bow is properly tuned and not torqued. The study controlled for tuning precisely so it could isolate the component variables.
“In the real world, a well-tuned bow with a quote-unquote mediocre setup will almost always outperform a poorly tuned bow with perfect components.” — Zakk Plocica
If your shop isn’t willing to help you tune, learn to do it yourself or find a shop that will. An untuned bow gives you erratic arrow flight and inconsistency, and then you start blaming yourself when the problem is the equipment. Zakk’s own default is to assume it’s the shooter — but you have to confirm the bow is shooting well first, and only then look at the arrow or yourself.
31:37What Changes at the Shop
Zakk closes the study out from the shop-owner side, because it’s changed the conversations happening at Extreme Outfitters.
Before the study, the FOC conversation was “it depends,” plus some general guidelines. Now there’s real data, so when someone comes in asking about FOC, the conversation can be about how to get them there efficiently — shortening the arrow, shaft GPI, vane weight — instead of defaulting to stacking point weight up front.
The broadhead and vane conversation shifts too. They’re not just asking what broadhead someone wants to run anymore; they’re asking what vane is going with it. If you want a quiet setup for pressured deer, that’s a system question, not two separate questions.
But the biggest thing the study reinforces for him in the shop is the tuning conversation. He sees bows come in that can barely keep an arrow on paper when you step back — guys who say the bow shoots great, and then it shows a six inch left tear through paper. So before broadhead selection, before vane choice, before FOC, they revisit tuning. He doesn’t think that will ever change.
His broader point is about what a good shop is for. Most people simply aren’t aware of this stuff, and that’s nobody’s fault — educating them is the job. Reading these studies is how a shop stays current and pulls out the pieces worth applying, both for their own builds and for the customers walking through the door.
“It’s not all opinion based stuff anymore. There’s good data, hard data to back it that we can reference and provide for the customers.” — Zakk Plocica
35:11Go Look at the Data Yourself — and Zakk’s Next Step
If you want to go deep on the data, everything is on the Precision Cut Archery site: all the interactive plots, hover over any dot for the numbers, click through to photos of the real arrow groups that produced them. Zakk calls it genuinely impressive. It’s also free, so use it. Extreme Outfitters also has FOC and kinetic energy calculators built into their site.
His own next step is addressing that 11.9% FOC on his FMJ Maxes, and by the end of the episode he’s talked himself most of the way into it. He’ll start by cutting the arrow down to see what the actual shift in FOC is, then retune and reshoot it. But he expects to end up on a lower GPI shaft — staying in the 5mm category, which he likes for component options and for how well it handles wind drift at distance. The goal is one good hybrid arrow that does everything, including reaching out far enough for the Western hunt he wants to do one day.
“That’s the real test. Not just a theory — how does it work on my setup, with my bow, the way the data says it could? I’ve got to find out.” — Zakk Plocica
He’ll report back with results in a future episode. And if you want to go deeper than this breakdown, he points to Yates in the Backcountry on YouTube — the FOC deep dive and perfect arrow build videos are both already out, and as the person who ran the study, Yates explains it better than anyone.
Gear & Resources Mentioned
Shop This Episode
- Custom Arrow Builds
- Easton Arrows
- Victory Arrows
- Broadheads
- Easton FMJ Max / Axis 5mm / Easton 5.0
- Easton HIT inserts
- SEVR 1.75 Hybrid
- Evolution Outdoors
- Beast Titanium
- Iron Will Solid
- Toulou broadheads
- Tooth of the Arrow
- AAE Talon & Hybrid HP
- AAE Max Stealth
- Flex Fletch 360 / 360X / 300
- DCA Super Sabre
- Bohning Heat
- UV Vane
Read the Study Yourself
Links
Extreme Outfitters: extremeoutfitters.com (code ARCHERYPROJECT for 10% off — FOC and kinetic energy calculators on site)
Instagram: @thearcheryproject
TikTok: @thearcheryproject
YouTube Clips: youtube.com/@thearcheryproject
YouTube Full Episodes: youtube.com/@thearcheryprojectpodcast
Enjoyed this episode? Leave a review — it’s the single biggest thing that helps new listeners find the show.
Rate on Apple Podcasts